Frequently asked questions
Straight answers from someone who's written too many evals.
Overview
›How does this work?
There are three entry points depending on who you are.
If you're the rater: Pick the rated soldier's rank, eval type, and your box check intent. Upload or paste their accomplishments. TopBlock generates the full eval — duty description, performance bullets, and overall narrative — in the right structure for that form. Review, regenerate anything that doesn't sound right (with optional guidance for the model), then copy section by section into EES.
If you're the rated soldier: You have two options: generate a full eval or just a support form. "Full draft" generates a completed eval with properly formatted bullets in PDF form so you can email it direct to your rater. "Support form" generates support form bullets ready to drop directly into EES yourself. Just don't forget to initiate afterward!
If you're the senior rater: TopBlock generates the senior rater narrative for you. Upload the rater's PDF draft, pick your box check intent, your narrative intent, and add any observations the rater might not have captured. TopBlock then generates the SR narrative and recommended assignments.
All options end with a copy-to-EES page with per-section copy buttons that match the EES format for inputting. So easy a caveman could do it.
About TopBlock
›How are the bullets actually generated?
Either upload a PDF (support form, an eval you wrote about yourself, chicken scratch accomplishments, etc.) or type them in to the appropriate boxes. TopBlock feeds those accomplishments plus your rated period info (rank, duty position, box check intent, narrative intent) into an AI model. This model is hard coded with all required EES rules, army writing style, and all evaluation regulations. The model then returns structured bullets that fit the form's character limits and all required Army rules and regulations. You review, edit, regenerate, then paste into EES.
Important disclaimer: The tool doesn't invent accomplishments. It only works with what you give it.
›Couldn't I just do this myself?
Absolutely! This is not rocket science. Anyone can feed a general AI model with information and ask it to make an eval. However, all current AI models require a lot of structure, prompting, guidance, and just general know-how to produce the right outcome. And it will very likely make a lot of mistakes that you might or might not even catch until HRC kicks your eval back.
TopBlock was specifically made with all of that in mind. The integrated model knows all current Army evaluation regulations, forms, EES structure, evaluation language requirements, army writing style, and general best practices. It exists because soldiers and senior leaders just don't have hours or days to work on evals (or learn AI) on top of our ever growing list of requirements.
If you want to do it all yourself, go for it. But if you just want it done - and done right - this tool is for you.
›What regulations is TopBlock built on?
AR 623-3, DA PAM 623-3, and EES and HRC guidelines. The system prompt also draws on lessons from actual evaluations — mine and others I've seen kicked back.
›What does it cost?
Free during testing. Paid plans coming once it's stable and being used by more people than current servers can handle.
Your data & safety
›Is my data stored anywhere?
No. TopBlock doesn't save your evaluations or any data to a database. When you close your browser, all data is gone.
›Can I upload classified or PII documents?
No. Don't upload anything containing PII (SSNs, full DOBs, family information) or classified information. The PDFs you upload get sent to the model's API for processing and then discarded — but the upload itself is your responsibility. Treat TopBlock the way you'd treat any commercial cloud tool.
If you're not sure whether your document is safe to upload, it probably isn't. Type the accomplishments in manually instead (and go take your annual Cyber Security).
›Is TopBlock approved by the Army?
No. TopBlock is not an official Army product. It's a personal drafting aid. You are always responsible for what you submit.
If your command has a policy against using AI tools for official writing, follow your command's guidance.
Common reasons evals get kicked back
These are the most common reasons evaluations get bounced back by S1 or HRC. TopBlock builds against most of them automatically, but knowing the list is useful for final review and submission.
Formatting
- Bullets that don't start with an action verb (NCOER)
- Bullets that don't start with the Soldier's name (OER)
- Bullets missing the lowercase "o" prefix
- Improper formatting, punctuation, or grammar (i.e. not writing in active voice)
Wrong content in the wrong place
- Rater comments on Soldier potential or promotion
- Bullets in OER narrative blocks (narratives only, no bullets)
- Bullets in NCOER Part V block b (SR narrative - no bullets)
- Improper SR language (i.e just sayings "concur with rater")
- Comments or language contradicting the box check
Administrative
- Missing counseling dates
- No AFT or AFT outside the rated period
- Comments about events outside the rated period
- Rater or SR not meeting the rank requirements or minimum amount of rated time
Prohibited content
- References to spouse, marital status, or family not tied to a soldier action
- References to race, sex, religion, sexual orientation, or national origin
- Comments on unproven investigations or NJP filed in restricted AMHRR
- Comments on protected communications (IG, Congressional)
- Selection board language ("multi-star potential," "definitely a 6+ Soldier")
- Box check references in narrative ("would be a top box if my profile supported it")
- Scholastic achievements as standalone bullets (limited to AERs)